One year after a collision at the Mandume Ndemufayo Road and Western Bypass interchange in Windhoek claimed the lives of three members of the same family, their relatives are still seeking answers about the circumstances surrounding the crash.
Willow Mae Martin (3), Letitia Angelina Sylvester (51) and Rhain Sylvester (18) died on 19 November 2025 when a truck carrying stones overturned and fell on the vehicle they were travelling in. On the first anniversary of their deaths, Reginald Hercules, who represents the families under a power of attorney, called on the Office of the Prosecutor-General to ensure that further investigations are completed without delay and that a decision on the case is made promptly. “We are not asking for anything extraordinary. We are asking the City to tell us whether the cameras and the signal data from that day still exist. We are asking the Prosecutor-General's Office to decide. We are asking the companies that put those vehicles on the road to answer in court. The least this family deserves is the truth about those few seconds and the records that hold that truth, which belong to public authorities,” he said.
Hercules highlighted that the criminal case remained unresolved. “The police docket, registered under case number CR 484-11-2025, was submitted to the Office of the Prosecutor-General in about August 2026 before being returned to the investigating officer by the control prosecutor for further investigation. One year after the collision, no prosecutorial decision has been made,” he said.
According to Hercules, the families had been seeking access to the evidence since 7 April 2026. They had repeatedly requested, in writing, the preservation and release of records that could establish what happened at the intersection. These include traffic signal phasing and timing data, traffic controller logs and any CCTV or other camera footage covering the interchange. Correspondence was also served on the Windhoek Municipal Police Service by the deputy sheriff and escalated to the City of Windhoek's chief executive officer, the investigating officer, the control prosecutor and the Office of the Prosecutor-General. “To date, not one of these records has been produced, and no authority has confirmed in writing whether the signal data and footage for 19 November 2025 still exist – or when, if ever, they were overwritten. The families ask one simple question of the City of Windhoek: does the evidence still exist – yes or no?” Hercules said.
He added that the families had instructed Isaacks and Associates to institute civil proceedings in the High Court of Namibia arising from the collision. The intended action concerns the e-hailing vehicle and its driver, operator and platform, as well as the second vehicle involved and its driver and operator. “Among the questions the proceedings will put before the court are whether the e-hailing driver and vehicle were authorised and licensed to convey passengers for reward, and whether the goods vehicle complied with the requirements applicable to it on that day. The families are claiming for the loss of support following the deaths of their loved ones, as well as the profound psychological injury suffered by surviving family members,” Hercules said.
The families had also engaged inspectors and experts to conduct a full reconstruction of the collision. “The reconstruction is the reason the signal data and camera footage matter so much and why their preservation has been demanded in writing since April 2026. Having placed every request, notice and item of evidence on record with the responsible authorities, the families' representative will now withdraw from public engagement so that the attorneys can do their work. The families ask the authorities to do theirs,” Hercules said.